
Detroit Presbytery
Adopted 120-77 at their
June 28, 2005 Meeting:
The Presbytery of Detroit respectfully
overtures the 217th General Assembly
(2006) of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.)
to do the following:
(A) Direct the Stated Clerk to send
the following proposed amendment to the
presbyteries for their affirmative or negative votes:
Shall
G-6.0106b be stricken?
(B) Approve the following authoritative
interpretation, which shall take effect
immediately upon the affirmative vote
of the 217th General Assembly
(2006):
“Interpretative statements concerning
ordained service by homosexual persons
by the 190 th General Assembly (1978) of
the United Presbyterian Church in the United
States of America, the 119 th General
Assembly (1979) of the Presbyterian
Church in the United States, and all subsequent
affirmations thereof, shall be given no
further force or effect.”
The Stated Clerk of Presbytery is directed
to send this overture to the Office of
the General Assembly as soon as possible following
Presbytery approval.
Rationale
- “God
alone is Lord of the conscience” (G-1.0301);
- The
Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) “believe(s)
that there are truths and forms with
respect to which men (sic) of good characters
and principles may differ” as
to which “it (is) the duty of both
private Christians and societies
to exercise mutual forbearance toward each
other” (G-1.0305);
- Those
who undertake particular ministries,
including those called to exercise special
functions in the church as deacons, elders
and ministers of Word and Sacrament, “should
be persons of strong faith, dedicated discipleship,
and love of Jesus Christ as Savior and
Lord . . . (whose) manner of life
should be a demonstration of the Christian
gospel in the Church and in the world.” (G-6.0106a);
- Presbyterians
of good characters and principles may differ
on the actions necessary to demonstrate
the Christian gospel in the church and
in the world;
- In
each church the congregation has the
power to nominate and elect deacons and
elders and the Session has responsibility
and power to examine the qualifications
of elders and deacons (G-6.0106a, G-10.0102l, and
G-14.0200);
- Each
Presbytery has the responsibility and
the power to ordain, receive, dismiss,
install, remove, and discipline Ministers
of the Word and Sacrament (G-11.0103n
and G-14.0101);
- G-6.0106b
is being used to exclude from elective
office baptized active members of
our churches who are “entitled to
all the rights and privileges of
the church, including the right . . . to
vote and hold office.” (G-5.0202);
- G-6.0106b
abridges the responsibility of sessions
and Presbyteries to determine the
readiness for office of active members.
(G-60108b: “The decision
as to whether a person has departed from
essentials of Reformed faith and
polity . . . ultimately becomes the responsibility
of the governing body in which he
or she serves. [G-1.0301 and G-1.0302]”);
- Historically,
persons of strong faith, dedicated discipleship,
and love of Jesus Christ (both heterosexual
and homosexual) have been elected and ordained
by their congregations and presbyteries;
- Although
G-6.0106b applies equally to heterosexual
and homosexual persons, its enforcement
is being directed only toward gay, lesbian, bisexual
and transgender persons; and
- Attempts
by the General Assembly and Permanent
Judicial Commission to resolve this issue
have consumed great amounts of time, energy
and money and have led to threats
of schism and other actions which endanger the
peace, purity and unity of the Church.